My apologies this response is a bit late but better to
destroy non-factual and ridiculous arguments later than never!
So in a response to Ruth Dudley Edwards absurd blog there arrived this supporting beauty posted on January 28th. I honestly didn’t think anything could beat Richard
Humphries article in the Irish Independent
but Mr. Hopper’s does.
To defeat his argument entirely and to save you from
absolute boredom, I (and you dear reader) need not go past the title. [I did
venture past the title and decided nothing in it was worth responding to as it
did not make Ireland any more or less unique than any other country in the
world. I let the facts speak for themselves in a few lines time] For Mr. Hopper
to begin as he did with such an inaccurate statement in the title - “ancient
hatreds” – was ridiculous. What ancient hatreds sir? There was a so-called ‘pogrom’ in Limerick in 1904 and
from the research I conducted I found nothing of serious note. A boycott
against Jewish business organised by a young Redemptionist Catholic priest [crazy
warning number 1] by the name of John Creagh
which unfortunately forced the Jewish population from their homes in Limerick
where many fled to Cork and they were welcomed into peoples own homes. That in
itself was a blessing. Have you been to Limerick?* It was a embarrassing and
disgusting period in Catholic Limerick history, not Irish history. Irish Protestants in Limerick supported the
Jewish people in Limerick, Corkonians welcomed them into their homes when the
Jewish people decided they (understandably) had to leave Limerick.
To quote from a letter sent to the Jerusalem Post by a retired History teacher, Leonard Hurley, I give you a small timeline of
Irish Jewish relations:
“Daniel
O’Connell, the “Liberator,” was responsible for the Catholic emancipation in
1829, but Honig failed to mention that he rejected anti-Semitism and in 1846,
in the House of Commons, helped repeal the law, De Judaismo, which
discriminated against Jews. O’Connell stated: “Ireland has claims on your
ancient race, it is the only country that I know of unsullied by any one act of
persecution against the Jews.”
Our [Mr.
Hurley’s] church is called the Daniel O’Connell Memorial Church, and buried on
the grounds is Msgr. Hugh O’Flaherty. O’Flaherty was given the title Righteous
Among the Nations by the Israeli government for the work he did in saving many
Jews in Rome during the war.
Many other Irish
historical figures, including Michael Davitt and John Redmond, rejected
anti-Semitism. Redmond stated: “Race hatred is at best an unreasoning passion.”
Both Dublin and
Cork have had Jewish lord mayors, and all political parties, including the
present government, have Jews in senior positions.
Of course, you
will find anti- Semitism in Ireland, but you will also find anti-Irish
sentiment if you look for it in other countries.
But the claim
that Ireland has a history of anti-Semitism is based on one disgraceful episode
and therefore is factually incorrect.
I suggest that
Honig visit the subject again and this time focus on the positive.”
Lastly I will add one more point: You’ll notice Mr Hurley
said definitively that what happened in Limerick was a pogrom. I personally
said ‘so-called’ pogrom in my paragraph above because in 2010 “the new Israeli ambassador,
Boaz Modai, speaking at the Jewish cemetery in Castletroy said: "I think
it [the ‘pogrom’] is a bit over-portrayed, meaning that, usually if you look up
the word pogrom it is used in relation to slaughter and being killed. This is
what happened in many other places in Europe, but this is not what happened
here. There was a kind of a boycott against Jewish merchandise for a while, but
that's not a pogrom. That's
something that is, unfortunately, a bad mark for the history of this city, but
I don't think it is something anyone should pay more attention to than it
deserves."
So Mr. Hopper, Ms. Dudley Edwards, Mr. Humphries and anyone
thinking they made any argument of sense, desist from your attempts to stir
shit due to some silly, silly peoples unfounded garbling and ill informed
writing. I am all for reasoned debate about proper issues in regard to
Israel and Ireland and actual anti-Semitism but your articles about my country
and its people were totally inaccurate and your smears laughable.
*Limerick people reading this – I jest! Don’t do anything
mad now
